The Ultimate Guide to the Pickleback Shot: Discover Whiskey’s Briny Companion

Are you a fan of pickles? Do you enjoy a good shot of whiskey, or perhaps you’re looking for a unique way to enjoy spirits? Then prepare to have your taste buds awakened, because there’s a fascinating drink sensation taking the beverage world by storm: the Pickleback shot.

While it might not be headline news across the globe, the Pickleback has steadily cultivated a dedicated following. If you’re someone who appreciates the tangy crunch of a dill pickle, this is a trend you’ll definitely want to explore. Even those who aren’t typically pickle enthusiasts might find themselves pleasantly surprised by this intriguing combination. It’s an experience that transcends mere novelty, offering a surprisingly harmonious pairing that challenges conventional drink wisdom.

My own introduction to this delightful concoction happened at a staff party, where our gracious host and bartender, Scott, unveiled the magic of the Pickleback. The concept, as he explained, is disarmingly simple, yet the resulting flavor profile is anything but ordinary.

What Exactly is a Pickleback Shot?

A Pickleback is elegantly straightforward: you take a shot of whiskey, and immediately after, you follow it with a shot of straight pickle juice. Yes, we’re talking about that tangy, briny liquid typically found at the bottom of a jar of mouth-puckering dill pickles. It’s not a mixed drink; it’s a two-step ritual that creates a singular and memorable taste experience.

The moment you take the whiskey shot, you feel its familiar warmth spread through your chest. But then, as the pickle juice follows, something remarkable happens. The intense tang of the brine instantly cuts through the sharp edge of the alcohol. Your mouth is left with a fresh, tingling sensation, a delightful zesty aftertaste that makes you want to smack your lips and perhaps even do a little “pickle dance.” For me, that first experience left such an impression that I found myself wanting another shot of pickle juice, almost as if it were a refreshing cool drink on a hot day.

The Unexpected History and Unofficial Science of the Pickleback

After my initial encounter, my curiosity was piqued, prompting me to delve into the origins of this peculiar drink. It turns out the Pickleback isn’t just a quirky local invention born from an adventurous party where the mixers ran out. This “thing” has a legitimate, albeit relatively recent, place in drinking culture.

The name “Pickleback” was famously coined by Reggie Cunningham in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, back in 2006. He reportedly introduced the concept at a dive bar called Bushwick Country Club, where it quickly caught on among patrons. However, the practice of chasing a shot with pickle juice, or even a bite of a pickle, likely existed in various forms long before it received its official moniker. Many cultures have traditions of pairing strong spirits with savory or acidic foods to balance the palate.

Beyond its cultural roots, there’s even some “unofficial science” that attempts to explain the Pickleback’s appeal and purported benefits. Proponents suggest that the acetic acid found in vinegar – a primary component of pickle brine – can help to neutralize the burning sensation of alcohol. Furthermore, it’s believed to aid in absorbing salt, potentially reducing the severity of hangovers, and even preventing muscle cramps. While these claims are largely anecdotal and not scientifically proven, many enthusiasts swear by the pickle juice’s ability to soothe the stomach and provide a refreshing cleanse after a strong drink.

Why the Pickleback Works: A Taste Sensation

For those who don’t frequently drink whiskey, or find its potent taste a bit overwhelming, the Pickleback offers a revolutionary way to enjoy it. The pickle juice doesn’t just chase the whiskey; it transforms the entire experience. It effectively neutralizes the harsh alcoholic burn, leaving behind a crisp, tangy, and surprisingly pleasant aftertaste. It’s this magical transformation that makes whiskey more palatable for many, opening up a new avenue for spirit enjoyment.

My own experience is a testament to this. I’m not a big whiskey drinker – in fact, I rarely touch it. Yet, the intrigue of the Pickleback was undeniable. My first attempt involved only a quarter-inch of whiskey, but even that small amount conveyed the unique effect. It was the pickle juice that truly won me over. Since then, I’ve had full shots for “research purposes,” of course, and can confirm that the Pickleback experience remains consistent and enjoyable without any undesirable side effects (like growing chest hair!).

Crafting the Perfect Pickleback: Ingredients Matter

The success of your Pickleback shot hinges entirely on the quality of your ingredients, particularly the pickle brine. This is not the time to reach for just any jar of pickles in your fridge.

Choosing Your Whiskey:

While you can certainly chase any kind of whiskey or scotch with pickle juice for a novel taste experience, my personal, if uninformed, suggestion leans towards a good Canadian rye whiskey. Canadian rye is often celebrated for its smoothness and approachable flavor profile, making it an excellent candidate for the Pickleback. It’s the “good stuff” derived from Canadian prairie-grown grains.

You don’t need to raid your bar for an expensive bottle of aged scotch or a nuanced single malt. A decent, everyday bottle of rye will perfectly suffice. The pickle brine has a strong flavor, and an overly complex or pricey whiskey might have its subtle notes completely overshadowed. The goal is a harmonious balance, not a competition.

Selecting Your Pickle Brine:

This is arguably the most crucial component. Avoid mass-produced, intensely yellow, vinegary supermarket pickles. Their brine is often too artificial, too sour, and lacks the depth needed for a truly satisfying Pickleback. Similarly, steer clear of sickly sweet juices from sugar-laden bread and butter pickles; they will clash horribly with the whiskey.

What you’re truly seeking is the lovely, salty, savory brine from a jar of really good quality dill pickles. Ideally, these should be artisanal or, even better, homemade ones. Look for pickles with a simple ingredient list: cucumbers, water, vinegar, salt, and natural flavorings like dill or garlic. The brine should be robust, tangy, and naturally balanced, providing that clean, zesty finish that makes the Pickleback so special.

How to Make and Enjoy Your Pickleback

The beauty of the Pickleback lies in its simplicity. Here’s how to prepare and savor this unique drink:

Pickleback Shots

• 1 shot* of your preferred whiskey (Canadian Rye is highly recommended for its smoothness).
• 1 shot* of high-quality pickle brine from a jar of good dill pickles (homemade or artisanal preferred, absolutely no sweet varieties).

Instructions:

1. Prepare Your Shots: Pour an equal-sized shot of whiskey into one shot glass and the pickle brine into another. Ensure both are ready for immediate consumption.
2. Take the Whiskey Shot: In one swift swallow, drink the whiskey. Feel its initial warmth.
3. Follow with the Brine: Immediately after the whiskey, take the shot of pickle brine.
4. Savor the Sensation: Feel the cleansing, zesty pickle aftertaste as it cuts through the whiskey’s burn, leaving your palate refreshed and invigorated.

There you have it – you’ve just experienced a Pickleback. This recipe serves one, and you can repeat the experience as many times as you like, though I am not responsible for the results after that first shot! 😉

*A standard shot of alcoholic beverage (containing 40% alcohol) is typically 1.5 fluid ounces (or 43ml). A pony shot is 1 ounce (30ml). However, the key is to pour equal amounts of both liquids into small glasses to ensure a balanced experience.

When to Serve the Pickleback

The Pickleback is more than just a drink; it’s a conversation starter and an adventurous addition to any gathering. It’s perfectly suited for:

• Holiday Festivities: Kick off your celebrations with a quirky, fun shot that will get everyone talking.
• New Year’s Toasts: Raise a glass to the new year with an unashamedly bold and slightly funky drink.
• Casual Get-Togethers: Impress your friends with a unique offering that’s far from the usual cocktails.
• BBQs and Outdoor Events: Its refreshing quality can be particularly enjoyable in a relaxed, informal setting.
• Dive Bar Adventures: Embrace the spirit of its origins in a no-frills environment.

So, whether you’re an avid pickle enthusiast or a curious whiskey drinker, give the Pickleback a shot (pun absolutely intended). It’s an adventure for your palate, a surprising delight, and a testament to how simple ingredients can create an extraordinary experience.

Cheers!

Want to receive new Kitchen Frau recipes directly to your email inbox? Sign up here and you’ll get a handy and useful kitchen tip along with each recipe, too.

If you like my recipes, follow me on Instagram, Pinterest, Twitter, and Facebook. You’d make my day!

You might also like these refreshing drink ideas:

Poinsettia Cocktail and Punch

Moscow Mule Cocktail

Cranberry Mulled Wine

Jam Smash Cocktail