Homemade Marshmallows: The Easiest No-Thermometer Recipe for Fluffy Perfection

Prepare yourself for a delightful culinary adventure. If the idea of making marshmallows from scratch has always seemed intimidating, requiring specialized equipment and precise temperatures, you’re in for a truly sweet surprise. This simple, no-thermometer method yields light, airy, and wonderfully fluffy homemade marshmallows that will melt in your mouth and impress everyone who tries them. Forget the store-bought variety; these old-fashioned treats are a revelation.

Imagine a treat so surprisingly easy to make, yet so incredibly delicious, that it prompts exclamations of “I can’t believe you made these yourself!” This isn’t just a recipe; it’s a journey back to simpler times, where homemade goodies were a staple, crafted with love and ingenuity. Our recipe comes from a cherished family cookbook, passed down through generations, and it’s a testament to the fact that the best things in life don’t always require complicated techniques.

The origin of this foolproof marshmallow recipe lies with my mother-in-law, Mabel, a true Canadian food hero from Northern Alberta. Reading through her cookbook, brimming with decades of culinary wisdom, it became clear that this was no ordinary recipe. Mabel has been perfecting her marshmallow craft for over 65 years, turning out countless batches of these special treats for her seven children during an era vastly different from our own. Picture this: a farmhouse kitchen warmed by a wood-burning stove, electric mixers being a rare luxury, and candy thermometers something only “city folk” might possess. My husband’s sister fondly recalls the children gathered in the kitchen, patiently passing the bowl around, each taking their turn to whip these marshmallows by hand until they reached perfect fluffiness. It’s a heartwarming image that speaks volumes about the enduring simplicity and joy of this recipe.

Indeed, I am incredibly grateful for the convenience of modern electric mixers these days! While the charm of hand-whipping is undeniable, achieving that cloud-like consistency is certainly made easier with a little mechanical assistance. This blend of old-world wisdom and new-world convenience makes marshmallow making accessible to everyone, regardless of their baking experience.

Before discovering Mabel’s method, my search for a homemade marshmallow recipe often led to a familiar sense of dread. Nearly every recipe I encountered, whether online or in my collection of cookbooks, invariably called for a candy thermometer. The instructions were always precise: heat the syrup to an exact, often high, candy-temperature stage, then carefully pour it in a thin, steady stream over dissolved gelatin while continuously beating. Many recipes also incorporated corn syrup alongside sugar, and some even included egg whites, adding another layer of complexity.

The most alarming part, however, was the lengthy lists of potential pitfalls. Recipes would often dedicate entire paragraphs to “why your marshmallows could fail,” detailing how they might not set, remain sticky, turn gummy, become curdled, clumpy, or weep. Yikes! Homemade marshmallows, it seemed, were a project reserved for the most intrepid and fearless cooks, certainly not for the faint of heart.

That was until I stumbled upon this gem – an authentic old Canadian prairie recipe. It’s so straightforward, so forgiving, that truly anyone can make them. Even I can make them, and I assure you, even you can too. This recipe strips away all the intimidation, proving that homemade marshmallows can be a simple pleasure, not a stressful science experiment.

The beauty of this recipe lies in its consistency and versatility. These marshmallows turn out wonderfully light and fluffy every single time, making you feel like a confectionery wizard. If you stick with classic white sugar, they deliver that familiar, comforting sweetness, tasting just like (if not better than!) the high-quality store-bought marshmallows you might remember from childhood. However, for those seeking a slightly healthier, refined-sugar-free option, substituting honey creates a delicately flavored marshmallow with a beautiful creamy hue. We’ve fallen completely in love with the honey version; its subtle floral notes add an extra layer of sophistication.

Once your pillowy marshmallow cubes are set, the fun truly begins with the finishing touches. You can roll them in a generous coating of icing sugar for a traditional look and extra sweetness, or opt for potato starch for a less sweet, more refined finish, particularly if you’re going for the honey version. For an elevated experience, try rolling them in toasted coconut, which adds a delightful texture and tropical aroma, or finely chopped toasted nuts like pecans, offering a rich, earthy crunch. Each coating transforms the simple marshmallow into a unique gourmet treat, perfect for any occasion.

And how best to enjoy these homemade delights? The possibilities are endless. Let them gently melt into lusciousness atop a steaming mug of hot chocolate, transforming your drink into a luxurious dessert. Their soft, ethereal texture makes them ideal for this classic pairing, creating a sweet, creamy layer that will warm you from the inside out.

Or, perhaps, the purest way to experience them is simply to pop one in your mouth and squish the sweet fluffiness with your tongue, letting it dissolve into a burst of sugary goodness. Each bite is a moment of pure, unadulterated bliss, a delightful reminder of the simple joys of homemade treats. Fair warning: these delectable morsels tend to disappear remarkably quickly. They get swiped by (almost) invisible hands as fast as I can make them, a testament to their irresistible charm and universal appeal!

* * * * *

Kitchen Frau Notes: When following Mabel’s original homemade marshmallow recipe, which uses white sugar, two packages of gelatin (typically 7 grams each, like Knox brand) yield a wonderfully soft and perfectly fluffy result. However, for the version that incorporates honey, I found it necessary to increase the gelatin to three packages. This slight adjustment compensates for the additional liquid present in the honey, ensuring the marshmallows set properly and maintain their signature light and airy texture. This small tweak makes all the difference for a consistently perfect batch.

For an adventurous and utterly delicious variation, consider trying these lovely pink Raspberry Honey Marshmallows. Made with real raspberry juice, they offer a beautiful color and a delightful fruity tang that complements the sweetness of the honey. It’s a fantastic way to experiment with flavors and add a vibrant twist to your homemade marshmallow repertoire.

Easy Old-Fashioned Homemade Marshmallows

From Mabel Johnson

• 1 cup (240ml) water, divided
• 2 packages gelatin (7 grams each) or 4½ teaspoons loose gelatin powder
• 2 cups (420gms) granulated sugar
• 1½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract
• ⅛ teaspoon salt
• Icing sugar to dust the pan
• Icing sugar, *toasted coconut (about 1¾ cup), or **finely chopped toasted pecans (about 1½ cups) to roll the marshmallows in

Instructions:

Begin by ‘blooming’ the gelatin. Sprinkle the gelatin evenly over ½ cup (120ml) of cold water in a small bowl or measuring cup. Stir very lightly with a fork to ensure all the gelatin is moistened. Allow it to sit undisturbed for at least 5 minutes, or until all the gelatin granules have softened and absorbed the water, becoming very thick and paste-like. This step is crucial for smooth marshmallow texture.

Meanwhile, in a medium-sized saucepan, combine the granulated sugar and the remaining ½ cup of water. Heat this mixture over medium heat, stirring occasionally, until the sugar is completely dissolved and the liquid is clear. Do not let it boil vigorously yet. Once the sugar is dissolved, add the bloomed gelatin to the sugar syrup, using a rubber spatula to scrape every last bit of gelatin from the bowl into the saucepan. Stir until the gelatin is fully incorporated.

Increase the heat and bring the mixture to a full, rolling boil. This means the bubbles will be large and continuous across the entire surface of the syrup, and you won’t be able to stir them down. This ensures the sugar reaches the proper consistency without needing a thermometer. Let it boil for about 30 seconds to a minute, just enough to be a vigorous boil, then remove the saucepan from the heat immediately.

Allow the hot syrup to cool. Let it sit undisturbed until it becomes lukewarm. This usually takes about 20 to 25 minutes. It’s important not to rush this step; the cooling process allows the mixture to reach the ideal temperature for whipping.

Carefully pour the lukewarm syrup into the clean bowl of a stand mixer. Add the pure vanilla extract and salt. Using the whisk attachment, beat the mixture on high speed. Continue beating until the mixture becomes very thick, glossy, and has tripled in volume, resembling a thick, whipped meringue. This process typically takes about 7 to 8 minutes with a stand mixer. If you’re using a rotary hand mixer, it might take a bit longer, perhaps up to 10 minutes, but the key is to beat until it achieves that fluffy, voluminous consistency.

While the marshmallow mixture is whipping, prepare your pan. Lightly grease a 9 x 13″ (23x33cm) baking pan. Then, generously dust the entire greased surface with icing sugar, ensuring every corner is coated. Tip the pan over and gently knock out any excess icing sugar. This creates a non-stick surface and prevents the marshmallows from sticking.

Once the marshmallow mixture has finished whipping, it will be incredibly sticky. Using a wet rubber spatula (wetting it prevents sticking), scrape the marshmallow mixture into the prepared pan. Use the wet spatula to gently smooth the top surface evenly. Try to work quickly as the mixture will start to set.

Allow the marshmallow mixture to set completely. This will take approximately 4 hours at cool room temperature, or less if you place it in the refrigerator. For best results, letting it set overnight ensures a firm, easy-to-cut consistency.

Once fully set, turn the marshmallow slab out onto a clean cutting board dusted with icing sugar. Using a sharp knife dipped in water between each cut, slice the marshmallow into desired squares or rectangles. If the top of the marshmallow mixture has dried out too much to adhere well to your chosen coating, simply wet your fingers and smooth a thin slick of water over the surface to lightly moisten it again.

Now for the finishing touch: roll the freshly cut marshmallow cubes in either icing sugar, *toasted coconut, or **finely chopped toasted nuts. If using icing sugar, gently shake off any excess. If using coconut or nuts, press the marshmallows down firmly into the coating to ensure they stick well on all sides. This adds flavor, texture, and prevents stickiness.

Place the coated marshmallows on a wire rack and allow them to air dry for an additional 3 to 4 hours. This step helps them develop a slight crust and prevents them from sticking together in storage. Once air-dried, store your delightful homemade marshmallows in an airtight container at cool room temperature for up to 2 weeks. They rarely last that long, though!

This recipe yields approximately 70 delicious homemade marshmallows, perfect for sharing, gifting, or simply indulging yourself.

*How to Toast Coconut: To achieve beautifully golden and fragrant toasted coconut, spread your coconut flakes evenly in a dry skillet over medium heat. Stir constantly once the coconut begins to brown, as it can burn very quickly. Continue toasting until it reaches your desired depth of golden-brown color and releases a rich aroma. Let it cool completely before using.

**How to Toast Pecans: To toast pecans, preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C). Spread the pecans in a single layer on a baking sheet. Bake for approximately 10 minutes, or until they become fragrant and lightly golden. Keep a close eye on them, as nuts can burn quickly. Once toasted, let them cool completely, then chop them very finely. This fine chop is essential to ensure they stick securely to the soft marshmallow surface.

Easy Honey Marshmallows

For a delicious, refined-sugar-free alternative, these honey marshmallows offer a subtly different flavor profile and a slightly creamier hue. The process is almost identical, with a key adjustment to the gelatin for perfect setting.

• 1 cup (240ml) water, divided
• 3 packages gelatin (7 grams each) or 2 tablespoons plus ¾ teaspoon loose gelatin powder
• 1 cup (240ml) liquid honey (choose a mild-flavored honey for best results)
• 1½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract
• ⅛ teaspoon salt
• Potato starch or other suitable starch (e.g., cornstarch) to dust the pan
• Potato starch or other starch, *toasted coconut (about 1¾ cup), or **finely chopped toasted pecans (about 1½ cups) to roll the marshmallows in

Instructions:

Follow the exact same preparation steps as for the Easy Old-Fashioned Homemade Marshmallows, with one crucial substitution: replace the granulated sugar with the 1 cup of liquid honey. Ensure you use 3 packages of gelatin for this version to account for the honey’s liquid content and achieve the desired set. The resulting marshmallows will have a delicate honey flavor and a lovely, slightly off-white color.

To maintain the refined-sugar-free integrity of these honey marshmallows, opt for potato starch (or another starch like cornstarch) to dust both the pan and the finished marshmallow cubes. Alternatively, toasted coconut or finely chopped nuts also make excellent sugar-free coatings, adding wonderful flavor and texture without added sweetness.

Guten Appetit!

Want to receive new Kitchen Frau recipes directly to your email? Sign up here and you’ll get a handy and useful kitchen tip along with each recipe, too. (No spam ever.)

If you like my recipes, follow me on Instagram, Pinterest, Twitter, and Facebook. You’d make my day!

You might also like these delightful treats:

Peanut Brittle Cravings

Healthy Fudge with a Wicked Alias

Decadent Little Truffles

Raspberry Gummies