Marcella Hazan’s 3-Ingredient Tomato Sauce: The Ultimate Guide to Effortless Italian Flavor

This iconic tomato sauce, boasting just four ingredients (if you count salt!), requires minimal preparation—a mere 2 minutes—and cooks to perfection in 45 minutes, delivering an unbelievably sumptuous and rich flavor that belies its simplicity. (Jump to the full recipe below.)

For years, I’d seen the whispers, then the shouts, across countless food blogs and culinary forums. Everyone, it seemed, was raving about a seemingly simple tomato sauce, a recipe that promised extraordinary flavor with astonishingly few ingredients. Its reputation preceded it, a culinary legend that pointed back to one source: the inimitable Marcella Hazan, from her foundational text, ‘Essentials of Classic Italian Cooking’. Curiosity piqued, I finally decided to put the hype to the test. Could something so basic truly be as magnificent as everyone claimed?

My verdict? A resounding, “Thank you, Marcella Hazan!” This recipe doesn’t just live up to the acclaim; it surpasses it. While I could easily wax poetic about its virtues for pages, I’ll spare you the lengthy ode. However, I absolutely must convey just how truly wonderful this simple tomato sauce is, because to miss out on it would be a genuine culinary tragedy. This isn’t just a recipe; it’s a revelation that will transform your perception of what a humble tomato sauce can achieve.

From the very first spoonful, you’ll discover a sauce that is remarkably rich, velvety smooth, and intensely tomato-forward, yet beautifully balanced with not a hint of excessive acidity. It’s a testament to the magic that occurs when premium ingredients are treated with respect and allowed to shine. Somehow, the unassuming combination of a humble can of tomatoes, a generous knob of butter, and half an onion undergoes an alchemical transformation. The result is a tomato sauce that is profoundly greater than the sum of its parts—a symphony of flavor orchestrated by just three core components (excluding salt, of course). Do not, for a moment, underestimate the transformative power within this simplicity.

Imagine sitting down to a perfectly al dente bowl of pasta, coated in this sumptuous sauce. Each bite is an escape, a momentary journey to a sun-drenched Italian villa. You might picture ancient Roman ruins crumbling under a warm sky, rows of cypress trees stretching across distant golden hills, and the faint, sweet strains of an Italian violin serenading your tastebuds. For those of us enduring frosty climes, it’s a welcome warmth that permeates the mind, the tummy, and the soul—a delightful escape, even if just in sensation, from the biting -27°C outside.

My culinary repertoire has always included a beloved go-to tomato sauce, one made with fragrant olive oil, fresh garlic, perhaps some savory ground beef, and a delightful array of Italian spices and vegetables. And let me be clear—that version remains a cherished family favorite. However, this new, unbelievably simple, yet exquisitely luscious sauce has carved out its own special place in my heart. Its vibrant, bright tomato-red hue, draped over a bed of white pasta, makes it an ideal choice for a romantic occasion, perhaps a cozy Valentine’s dinner, serving beautifully as either a starter or a memorable main course. To elevate it further as a main, simply pair it with a crisp, fresh green salad, a few slices of excellent dry Italian salami, and some crusty bread for dipping, all accompanied by a glass of fine vino. Its elegance lies in its unpretentious perfection.

Throughout my journey with this blog, my primary aim has always been to share innovative recipes, those I’ve meticulously developed, tinkered with, and perfected through endless experimentation. Yet, there are rare occasions when a recipe stands so perfectly on its own, so inherently flawless, that any attempt to “improve” it would be an act of culinary hubris. Why, after all, attempt to reinvent a wheel that already spins with such elegant efficiency? Marcella Hazan’s simple tomato sauce is precisely one such masterpiece—a testament to the adage that sometimes, the greatest culinary achievements are born from profound simplicity rather than complex layers.

So, it is with immense pleasure that I pass on to you this beautifully simple and utterly perfect recipe. While its origin lies firmly with the culinary icon Marcella Hazan, it has since whirled its way across the internet, transforming countless kitchens and palates, much like a delightful game of culinary “telephone” gone wonderfully right. Prepare to be amazed by how such minimal effort can yield such profound, restaurant-quality flavor.

* * * * *

Kitchen Frau Notes: Essential Tips for Marcella Hazan’s Simple Tomato Sauce

Crafting this incredible sauce relies heavily on the quality of your ingredients. It truly is paramount to start with an excellent brand of canned whole peeled tomatoes. Avoid any tomatoes canned in water, as these often lack the deep, concentrated flavor necessary for this recipe. While San Marzano tomatoes are universally recommended for their sweet, tender flesh and balanced acidity (and are certainly worth splurging on if you can find them), I’ve found that other reputable brands like Unico or Primo can yield similarly fantastic results. The key is seeking out whole, peeled tomatoes packed in their own juice, preferably from Italy.

Furthermore, and this is a crucial directive for preserving the integrity of this exquisite sauce: do not be tempted to adulterate it with Parmesan cheese. While Parmesan is a beloved staple in Italian cuisine and often a welcome addition to many pasta dishes, it will completely overpower the subtle, delicate richness imparted by the butter—a richness you’ve lovingly nurtured through a slow, patient simmer. This sauce’s beauty lies in its elegant simplicity; allow its core flavors to shine unmasked.

Lastly, nearly every online rendition of this recipe instructs you to discard the onion halves once the sauce is finished. I implore you: do not heed this advice! The onion, having slowly simmered in the buttery tomato bath, becomes incredibly sweet, tender, and deeply flavorful. Remove it carefully, place it in a small bowl, and allow it to cool slightly. Then, sprinkle it with a touch of salt and savor each sweet, tangy, buttery forkful slowly. It is, in itself, a heavenly treat and a delightful preview of the sauce to come. Be warned, however: you might have to begrudgingly share if anyone wanders into the kitchen while you’re in the midst of this blissful indulgence!

Simple Tomato Sauce (Marcella Hazan’s Classic Recipe)

Adapted from Marcella Hazan’s ‘Essentials of Classic Italian Cooking’

This recipe requires just 2 minutes of active preparation and a relaxing 45 minutes of simmering time.

Ingredients:

• 1 large can (28-oz / 800gms) high-quality peeled, whole tomatoes (San Marzano recommended)
• ⅓ cup (5 tablespoons / 75gms) salted butter (you may reduce to ¼ cup, but no less, for richness)
• 1 medium onion, peeled and halved crosswise
• Salt, to taste

Instructions:

1. Empty the entire contents of the can of tomatoes, including their juice, into a medium-sized saucepan or a Dutch oven.
2. Add the butter to the pot, then place the two onion halves into the sauce, gently pushing them down so they are submerged in the liquid.
3. Place the pot over medium heat and bring the sauce just to a gentle boil. As soon as it begins to bubble, reduce the heat to a low simmer. Allow it to simmer, uncovered, for approximately 45 minutes.
4. During the simmering process, stir the sauce occasionally. Use a wooden spoon to gently squish the whole tomatoes against the side of the pot, breaking them up as they soften.
5. Continue to simmer until the sauce has significantly reduced, thickened, and no watery liquid remains. The sauce will develop a rich, cohesive texture, and you will notice the buttery oil beginning to separate slightly from the tomato base. It will “plop and bubble” gently, but the presence of the onion halves remarkably helps to prevent excessive splattering.
6. Once the desired consistency is reached, carefully remove and set aside the cooked onion halves (don’t discard them!).
7. Season the sauce lightly with salt to taste.
8. (Optional: Some cooks prefer a smoother sauce and choose to puree it at this stage. However, I find its best character shines through when left chunky and rustic, celebrating the natural texture of the tomatoes.)

Serving Suggestion:

Serve this exquisite sauce generously over your favorite al dente pasta. It is perfect as is, requiring no further embellishments or additions. Its pure flavor is its greatest asset.

Pro Tip: Given the minimal effort involved in stirring and waiting, I highly recommend making a double batch. This sauce freezes beautifully, ensuring you always have a taste of Italy ready for a quick and delicious meal – if it even makes it to the freezer!

Guten Appetit!

Want to receive new Kitchen Frau recipes directly to your email? Sign up here and you’ll get a handy and useful kitchen tip along with each recipe, too. (No spam ever.)

If you like my recipes, follow me on Instagram, Pinterest, Twitter, and Facebook. You’d make my day!

You might also like these delicious recipes:

Eggplant, Kale and Cannellini Bean sort-of Ratatouille with Poached Eggs

Honey Mustard and Three-Seed Encrusted Pork Tenderloin with Parsnip Mashed Potatoes

Fish Tacos – Fresh, Crispy and Colourful (and oh-so-full of flavour)

Pasta Sauce with Sardines and Capers