Glorious Heirloom Tomato Salad Caprese Style: A Perfect Summer Delight

Experience the true taste of summer with this incredibly simple yet profoundly flavorful Heirloom Tomato Salad. Imagine sweet, succulent, vine-ripened tomatoes, generously layered with creamy fresh mozzarella, fragrant basil leaves plucked straight from the garden, and finished with a delicate, tangy vinaigrette. This dish isn’t just a recipe; it’s a celebration of peak season produce and one of summer’s most cherished, classic pleasures.

Jump to the full recipe below!

Summer is truly at its glorious zenith, blessing us with sensationally hot and sunny days that make every moment feel vibrant and full. Life seems to swell with richness, particularly in the garden, which has burst forth with an abundance that can only be described as riotous. Plants sprawl exuberantly into pathways, playfully falling over each other, while flowers bloom in a kaleidoscope of dazzling colors. It’s a joyful struggle to keep up with the sheer volume of produce bursting from the earth. This is, without a doubt, a time of incredible plenty, a period when nature generously offers its finest gifts.

The Garden’s Bounty and Its Persistent Challenges

While the market often provides a wonderful selection, there’s nothing quite like the satisfaction of growing your own. Our garden, despite its wild beauty, tells a story of both triumph and tribulation. Everything is growing splendidly—or at least, everything that the local deer and a particularly tenacious mole haven’t managed to pillage. The year 2020, as many will recall, proved to be exceptional in many ways, including the tenacity of our local wildlife. We’ve faced unprecedented challenges with deer, those dastardly animals that sneak into our garden night after night, raiding whatever delights their fancy.

Battling the Backyard Bandits

We’ve employed a variety of tactics against these persistent visitors, with varying degrees of success. Posts tied with strongly perfumed soap were placed around the perimeter—no luck. Wire cages over the rows? They simply nibbled around and even through them. Our latest, and hopefully most effective, defense involves pounding stakes all around the garden and stringing two rows of heavy-duty nylon fishing line. The theory we heard is that deer can’t see the lines but are startled by the unfamiliar feel as they push against them, and because the barrier is invisible, they can’t accurately gauge how to jump over it.

So far, this new strategy has worked! We’re crossing our fingers that it proves to be the final, lasting solution to our deer problems. Our efforts to protect our beloved crops, like the honey-rhubarb ice cream ingredient rhubarb, have been exhaustive.

Then there’s the mole. A cunning little bugger, he’s managed to evade our traps, burrowing tirelessly under rows, creating mounds of dirt, and unfortunately, killing the plants he digs among. We’ll continue our mission to evict him, but in the meantime, I’m trying to harvest what we can before he gets to it.

Anticipating Our Own Tomatoes

Our garden tomatoes, a source of much anticipation, are still stubbornly green and hard. This is often the consequence of gardening in northern climates, where the growing season is shorter. But I know that these beauties will eventually ripen, allowing us to enjoy their homegrown flavor later in the fall. The wait makes the eventual harvest all the more rewarding.

The Allure of Heirloom Tomatoes

So, when I spotted these breathtakingly beautiful, perfectly ripe heirloom tomatoes at the local market, I simply couldn’t resist. Their weighty feel, intense sweetness, and undeniable juiciness spoke of pure summer perfection. These aren’t just any tomatoes; heirloom varieties offer a spectrum of colors, shapes, and complex flavors that supermarket varieties can only dream of. From deep purples and striped greens to vibrant reds and sunny yellows, their glowing jewel tones and rich, nuanced taste require little adornment to shine. This is where the magic of a simple heirloom tomato salad truly begins.

Crafting the Perfect Caprese-Style Heirloom Tomato Salad

Inspired by the classic Italian Caprese Salad, I nestled tender slices of soft, fresh mozzarella cheese among the tomatoes and scattered a generous handful of fragrant basil leaves, freshly picked from our garden, over the top. The beauty of this Caprese-style heirloom tomato salad lies in its delightful simplicity and rustic charm. There’s no need for fuss or complicated preparations. Just a few cuts, and you can arrange the slices or chunks artfully on a plate. The spectacular, natural colors of the heirloom tomatoes provide all the visual beauty you need, making it an effortlessly elegant centerpiece.

While a true Caprese Salad, originating from the sun-drenched island of Capri, is traditionally dressed with nothing more than a sprinkle of salt, a crack of pepper, and a generous glug of the finest olive oil (sometimes with a splash of balsamic vinegar), I took a delightful riff on the classic. For this heirloom tomato salad, I opted for a simple French vinaigrette, subtly sweetened with a touch of white balsamic vinegar. This particular dressing is incredibly light and just tangy enough to beautifully enhance and bring out the natural sweetness inherent in the heirloom tomatoes. The result is utterly divine, a perfect symphony of fresh flavors that dance on the palate.

If you’re fortunate enough to find some beautiful heirloom tomatoes, this simple yet stunning salad is an absolutely delicious and perfect way to showcase their unique charm and exquisite flavor. It’s an ideal dish to serve as an elegant first course, or as a vibrant accompaniment to a light pasta dish or grilled meats. Imagine enjoying this beautiful summer meal outdoors, perhaps in the dappled shade of a tree, with the gentle sounds of birds chirping nearby. It’s more than just food; it’s an experience, a moment of pure culinary bliss.

Happy Summer Eating!

* * * * *

Tips for Crafting the Best Caprese-Style Heirloom Tomato Salad

Kitchen Frau Notes: The unparalleled success of this Caprese-Style Heirloom Tomato Salad hinges almost entirely on the quality of its ingredients. To achieve that truly exceptional taste, you must seek out the freshest, ripest, sweetest, and juiciest tomatoes—ideally those sun-ripened and bursting with the essence of summer. Complement these with crisp, aromatic basil leaves, and tender, moist fresh mozzarella. Avoid the springy pizza-style mozzarella; it won’t absorb the delicious juices from the tomatoes and simply won’t yield the same creamy, delightful texture. For an equally wonderful experience, you can also use bocconcini slices. If fresh mozzarella or bocconcini isn’t available, don’t despair! You can still create a fantastic plain heirloom tomato salad, allowing the natural splendor of the tomatoes to shine entirely on their own.

A personal tip: I often like to whip up a double batch of this simple vinaigrette. It’s an incredibly light, mild, and versatile dressing that stores beautifully in a sealed jar in the refrigerator. Having it on hand makes it incredibly convenient for dressing any kind of green salad or a vibrant vegetable salad throughout the week. Its subtle tang and sweetness are universally pleasing.

Heirloom Tomato Salad, Caprese Style – The Recipe

Ingredients:

• 3 large, ripe, juicy heirloom tomatoes (approximately 1½-2 lbs / 700-900gms) or your finest sweet vine-ripened garden tomatoes
• 1 ball (250gms) of fresh mozzarella (Fior’ di Latte is ideal)
• 1 small handful of fresh basil leaves, torn

For the Vinaigrette Dressing:

• 1 tablespoon white balsamic vinegar
• ½ tablespoon white wine vinegar
• 6 tablespoons (90ml) high-quality olive oil or avocado oil
• 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
• ¼ teaspoon salt
• ⅛ teaspoon black pepper

Instructions:

1. Begin by carefully slicing your heirloom tomatoes to about pencil thickness. For the fresh mozzarella, slice it just a little bit thinner than your tomato slices to ensure it melts beautifully with the tomato’s juices.
2. On your chosen serving platter, artfully arrange the tomato slices, slightly overlapping them. After every third tomato slice, tuck in a slice of mozzarella. This layering technique ensures an even distribution of flavors and textures. Any extra bits of tomatoes can be piled attractively into the middle of the platter, and any unused pieces of cheese can be torn and scattered over the center as well.
3. Once the tomatoes and mozzarella are arranged, tear the fresh basil leaves into small pieces and generously scatter them over the entire salad. The aroma of fresh basil is key to this dish.
4. To prepare the vinaigrette, combine all the dressing ingredients into a small jar. Secure the lid tightly and shake it vigorously until the dressing is beautifully emulsified and creamy.
5. Finally, drizzle the vinaigrette sparingly over the salad platter. The goal is to enhance, not overwhelm, the delicate and natural flavors of the heirloom tomatoes. You will likely not use all of the vinaigrette; simply save the remaining dressing in the fridge. It makes an excellent, versatile dressing for other green salads or various vegetable salads throughout the week.

This recipe generously serves 4, or 6 with smaller individual servings.

Guten Appetit!

Want to receive new Kitchen Frau recipes directly to your email? Sign up here and you’ll get a handy and useful kitchen tip along with each recipe, too. (No spam ever.)

If you like my recipes, follow me on Instagram, Pinterest, Twitter, and Facebook. You’d make my day!

PIN IT HERE to save the recipe for later:

You might also like these other fresh and flavorful salad recipes:

Summer Herb Vinaigrette and Zucchini Salad

Basil Beet Salad with Bocconcini

Swiss Green Salad with Creamy Dressing and Chopped Egg

Chopped Salad with Simple Vinaigrette